Gilda's Skaneateles

4.7 ( 267 reviews )
$20–30
12 W Genesee St, Skaneateles, NY 13152, United States
+1 315-685-7234

Gilda's Skaneateles, nestled in the heart of Skaneateles at 12 W Genesee St, is a charming pizza restaurant that has garnered rave reviews from locals and visitors alike. The intimate atmosphere, characterized by a small bar and limited tables, fosters a delightful dining experience where guests can feel connected to their food and friends. Patrons praise the friendly, knowledgeable staff who are always ready to recommend delightful dishes.

The menu, while focused on gourmet pizzas, also features enticing small plates, sandwiches, and tempting desserts. Highlights include ‘Sam's Favorite Pizza’ and the irresistible chocolate budino that leaves guests wanting more. Reviewers frequently commend the shrimp cakes for their exceptional flavor and creativity. However, be prepared for a wait during busy times, as tables are limited and reservations are not accepted.

Overall, Gilda's Skaneateles stands out not just for its delicious food but also for its welcoming vibe and commitment to quality. Many review it as one of the best dining spots in town, where every visit feels special. With a well-curated wine list and attentive service, this eatery proves to be more than just a pizza place; it's a cherished community gem.

Amenities and More

  • Service options
    • Outdoor seating
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
    • Delivery
  • Highlights
    • Fast service
    • Great wine list
  • Popular for
    • Lunch
    • Dinner
    • Solo dining
  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Offerings
    • Alcohol
    • Beer
    • Coffee
    • Comfort food
    • Small plates
    • Vegetarian options
    • Wine
  • Dining options
    • Lunch
    • Dinner
    • Catering
    • Dessert
    • Seating
    • Table service
  • Amenities
    • Gender-neutral toilets
    • Toilet
  • Atmosphere
    • Casual
    • Cosy
    • Romantic
    • Trendy
  • Crowd
    • Tourists
  • Planning
    • Accepts reservations
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards
  • Children
    • High chairs
  • Parking
    • Parking

Reviews For Gilda's Skaneateles

Nicolas Dessein
Jun 23,2025
Great little restaurant with awsome food. Nothing crazy but right on point. Deff the best place in the DT of the town. Super friendly staff, very knowledgeable and educated on what they propose. I will go there every night if I could. Wine list : B Staff : A Food : A Service: A Atmosphere: B Location: A
N N
Jun 20,2025
This is basically a gourmet pizza place with several small-plate options, two sandwiches (chicken and a burger) and a lively bar. I ordered 'Sam's Favorite Pizza' and it was excellent. I also enjoyed a chocolate budino for dessert. They do not take reservations and there are very few tables, Even arriving at 4:45 p.m. on a Tuesday in early December, we had to wait sometime for a table. We could have eaten at the bar but we were meeting someone we hadn't seen in some time and we wanted a more private setting to catch up on news. Our experience with the staff were mixed. The woman who took our food order seemed indifferent as to whether we ate there or not, whereas the friendly fellow who initially took our request for a table and delivered some of our food was welcoming and helpful.
Joe Masucci
Jun 15,2025
First timer for an early dinner. Beautiful location. Clean place. Friendly staff. Good pricing. We tried two different pizza's and they were AMAZING. That was enough food for two adults and two children, but we smelled the french fries that were brought to the next table and we had to try them. Also amazing! And while we were full we also tried a desert ( just one for the table to share). It was simply amazing. These folks have their act together. This is a five star place no doubt.
J Jeon
Apr 30,2025
I tried the beet and burrata salad, shrimp cakes, and peppadew pie pizza at this restaurant and I enjoyed them all. The shrimp cakes, in particular, were awesome; I could easily eat ten of them. The restaurant's vibe was also enjoyable. Due to the small space, the tables are also small and the space between them is narrow. There isn't a specific parking area for the restaurant, but you can easily find parking nearby. Overall, I had a great time and would definitely come back again.
Rick Vattimo
Apr 27,2025
Charming, small restaurant with a great feel. Small bar and only a handful of tables gives an intimate feeling and you can see into the kitchen at the corner of the bar. Nice wine and beer selection and a small but creative menu. Food sensitivities and allergies are listed clearly on the menu. Had the veal meatballs on the recommendation of a very friendly and good bartender, very tasty.
Ed L
Apr 6,2025
We went for a midweek dinner, and viola, it was "Wine Wednesday" where all bottles are 1/2 price. Yippee. Small venue in the Skaneateles village, no rezzies unless a party of 6 or more. Cool vibe, many small plates, great servers and service. It will not be our last visit. We split starters of shrimp cakes and fried cauliflower and then shared a delicious 4 cheese pizza, but needed 2 takeout boxes. The cauliflower was 2x the size I was expecting, but not at all heavy. I felt that I was losing weight as I ate it. Shrimp cakes were delish, and the pizza was perfect, thin crust artisan style. We went early, it fills up quickly so you need to consider that. Food 5 of 5 Service 5 of 5 Vibe 5 of 5 Try it!!
Cole Leto
Apr 1,2025
Any time we stop in Skaneateles we have to grab a pizza from here. The one hour drive from Endicott NY is worth it for the view and always tasty pizza. The “special” never disappoints.
D M
Mar 7,2025
Lovely atmosphere and delicious food. The owner Bill and our waitress Bella were great! So glad we stopped here on our road trip. Try the mushroom pizza!

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

La Hacienda Del Sazon
(263 review)
La Hacienda Del Sazon
  • 1685 U.S. Hwy 395 N # B, Minden, NV 89423, United States
Mexican restaurant
+1 775-782-5539
Pelato
(314 review)
Pelato
  • 1085 Morrison Dr, Charleston, SC 29403, United States
restaurant
+1 843-936-1085
Lotus
(194 review)
Lotus
  • 42 Barton St, Tewkesbury GL20 5PR, United Kingdom
restaurant
+44 1684 293851
Squid Jigger on Caplin Bay
(193 review)
Squid Jigger on Caplin Bay
  • NL-10, Calvert, NL A0A 1N0, Canada
restaurant
+1 709-432-3330
Wright Brothers Battersea Power Station
(1420 review)
Wright Brothers Battersea Power Station
  • Battersea Power Station, 26 Circus West Village, London SW11 8EZ, United Kingdom
Fish and seafood restaurant
+44 20 7324 7734
Tasty's
(634 review)
Tasty's
  • 9425 Blue Ridge Blvd, Kansas City, MO 64138, United States
fast food restaurant
+1 816-569-1618
Shiro Sushi
(442 review)
Shiro Sushi
  • 100 Broadgate, London EC2M 2QS, United Kingdom
Japanese restaurant
+44 20 3873 8252
Fresh Bowl Go
(103 review)
Fresh Bowl Go
  • 3419 Broadway Ground floor, Astoria, NY 11106, United States
fast food restaurant
+1 718-808-1888
North Hi-Way Cafe
(1303 review)
North Hi-Way Cafe
  • 460 Northgate Mile, Idaho Falls, ID 83401, United States
Cafe
+1 208-522-6212
Almazónica Cervecería & Peruvian Eatery
(340 review)
Almazónica Cervecería & Peruvian Eatery
  • Next to Orange Octopus Ice Cream Store, 4141 S Tamiami Trl suite 16, Sarasota, FL 34231, United States
restaurant
+1 941-260-5964